Issue 3 · Case 4 · 19 August 2026
Bombay civic desk · 1979 · Prabha Naik
The Mazgaon Pass Book
A dock pass book was signed in the wrong hand during a 1979 rain delay.
REPORT: Mazgaon, 1979 — A dock office found a pass book signed in the wrong hand while rain delayed a small cargo movement. The gate clerk, tallyman, crane helper and runner had entries at the gatehouse, tally shed, covered quay and tool hut alongside a pass stamp, manifest tag, locker key and tea flask. The four statements cannot all be treated alike. The desk adds one line for the record: the false claim in the signed statements came from the very person this enquiry wants.
Drain map receives a patient red-pencil update
At a Girgaon committee table, residents marked recurring puddles on a folded drain map before the monsoon repair meeting began in earnest.
Bina Sawant enters the evening register
The rain-delay log names Bina Sawant beside the Gatehouse in the route column.
Wet roads slow the late bus past the market lane
A steady afternoon shower left the market-side road slow but passable, with conductors calling for careful footing near the temporary wooden planks.
Pass stamp is named in the station paperwork
Bina Sawant's line in the gate issue book records the Pass stamp for the file.
Junior draftsman completes the ward filing course
After evening practice with a stencil duplicator and red cloth files, a municipal trainee finished the office’s internal filing course with a tidy set of labels.
Ledger copy keeps Mumtaz Ali on the record
A handwritten line in the rain-delay log assigns Mumtaz Ali to the Tool hut before filing.
CLASSIFIED
Dock pass covers stitched in oilcloth
Mazgaon Gate Supply protects pass books from rain, fish scales, and the handwriting of men in a hurry.
Monsoon play rehearsal moves into the community hall
A local troupe has shifted its evening rehearsal indoors, where borrowed chairs and a typed agenda share space with a modest painted backdrop.
CLASSIFIED
Signed copy leaves Bina Sawant where readers can find it
A countersigned dock statement records Bina Sawant with the Tally shed.
Umbrellas left at the ward counter await owners
Three plain umbrellas are held at the civic counter until Friday evening. Owners should describe the handle before taking one home through the rain.
Evening copy names Tally shed before closing
Albert D’Souza's signed line names the Tally shed; the tally decides whether it holds.
CLASSIFIED
Red Tile Irani Café sets out the afternoon papers
Red Tile Irani Café keeps bun maska, khari and strong chai ready beside a rack for damp newspapers. Please shake raincoats outside before taking a table.
Raghav Pillai enters the evening register
The dock statement records Raghav Pillai's claim about the Locker key.
Harbour studio sends back a repaired folder clip
A small metal folder clip arrived with the post from a harbour broadcast room, another ordinary object moving quietly through the case-world record.
Tea flask is named in the station paperwork
Mumtaz Ali entered the Tea flask in the statement column.
Ledger copy keeps one name on the record
The dock office edition prints four claims because the desk must find one false line.
Deduction board
| Deduction groups | Suspects | Implements | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rows | ||||||||