Issue 4 · Case 3 · 23 August 2026
Bombay local lines · 1988 · Ramesh Soman
The Lower Parel Voucher
A 1988 workshop voucher named an uncollected bearing.
REPORT: Lower Parel, 1988. A stores voucher records a bearing as collected, but the machine-floor foreman has not received it. The workshop has paused that repair while staff check the release of the part. Four workers have signed accounts of their duties. The enquiry must distinguish the missing bearing from the paperwork that claims it left stores. The purchasing supervisor checked the four accounts against the bearing order and the delivery papers. The person who gave the false statement is responsible for this incident. Identify that person, the place they visited and the item they carried.
Footpath repainting leaves a clear path to the crossing
A Churchgate ward crew finished a fresh white edge near the crowded crossing, asking pedestrians to use the temporary route until the paint dried.
Witness tally flags one false claim
In the workshop bearing enquiry, among the four signed statements, exactly one is false.
Evening handover brings a light platform shower
The evening rush arrived with a short shower and careful umbrella folding, while the suburban-local handover continued beneath the station’s familiar announcements.
Vinod Suri's signed account enters the tally
Vinod Suri stated: “I carried the Socket wrench.”
Parcel clerk earns praise for a tidy delivery register
A young parcel clerk completed a month of careful entries in the delivery register, keeping twine bundles and return slips in their allotted tray.
Accounts cubicle and Dispatch tag entries do not match
In the workshop bearing enquiry, the visitor to the Accounts cubicle did not carry the Dispatch tag.
CLASSIFIED
Bearing boxes labelled in red pencil
Lower Parel Tool Room marks bearing boxes, socket trays, and vouchers before the machine floor begins asking sharp questions.
Platform bookstall hosts a small poetry reading
After the evening crowd thinned, a bookstall owner will read three short poems beside the magazine stack, with a black roadster bicycle leaned outside.
Cecil D’Mello's signed account enters the tally
Cecil D’Mello signed this account: “I carried the Socket wrench.”
Parcel receipts must be collected before closing
Customers expecting a twine-bound parcel are requested to bring the counter slip before the final collection bell, leaving the narrow window free for the next queue.
Parul Jain's signed account enters the tally
Parul Jain wrote: “I carried the Voucher pad.”
CLASSIFIED
Monsoon Clock Irani Café keeps a seat for readers
Monsoon Clock Irani Café serves brun pav, bun maska and chai for travellers between platforms. A folded newspaper is welcome; dripping parcels are not.
Cecil D’Mello's handling record names two items
Cecil D’Mello's item was either the Socket wrench or the Voucher pad.
Girgaon clerk returns a borrowed red cloth file
A red cloth file was returned through the evening post with no note beyond a careful date stamp, linking two otherwise ordinary Bombay desks.
Nandita Bhosle's signed account enters the tally
Nandita Bhosle said, “I visited the Accounts cubicle.”
Stores hatch traced to the Socket wrench record
In the workshop bearing enquiry, the visitor to the Stores hatch carried the Socket wrench.
Machine aisle and Voucher pad entries do not match
The visitor to the Machine aisle did not carry the Voucher pad.
Deduction board
Confirming a pair rules out the other cells in its row and column.
Blank → ○ possible → × ruled out → ✓ matched.
Swipe to compare. Match each icon to the key below.
| 1Parul Jain | 2Nandita Bhosle | 3Cecil D’Mello | 4Vinod Suri | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1Bearing box | ||||
| 2Socket wrench | ||||
| 3Voucher pad | ||||
| 4Dispatch tag |
| 1Parul Jain | 2Nandita Bhosle | 3Cecil D’Mello | 4Vinod Suri | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1Machine aisle | ||||
| 2Accounts cubicle | ||||
| 3Stores hatch | ||||
| 4Loading dock |
| 1Bearing box | 2Socket wrench | 3Voucher pad | 4Dispatch tag | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1Machine aisle | ||||
| 2Accounts cubicle | ||||
| 3Stores hatch | ||||
| 4Loading dock |
File your accusation
Reading your saved case…
Icon key
| 1Sus 1 | Parul Jain |
|---|---|
| 2Sus 2 | Nandita Bhosle |
| 3Sus 3 | Cecil D’Mello |
| 4Sus 4 | Vinod Suri |
| 1Imp 1 | Bearing box |
|---|---|
| 2Imp 2 | Socket wrench |
| 3Imp 3 | Voucher pad |
| 4Imp 4 | Dispatch tag |
| 1Loc 1 | Machine aisle |
|---|---|
| 2Loc 2 | Accounts cubicle |
| 3Loc 3 | Stores hatch |
| 4Loc 4 | Loading dock |